LegalClicks
How automation via AI Bots/Agents can damage your client experience and reputation
As AI continues to dominate headlines, many businesses have rushed to integrate automated chat systems into their websites, believing it will modernise client communication and save valuable time. For law firms, however, the reality has often been quite different. At LegalClicks, we have recently seen a surge of firms reaching out to us for help after finding themselves in difficult situations created by poorly controlled or misaligned Rogue AI Chatbots chatbot systems.
What initially seemed like a clever innovation quickly became a liability. The chatbot, once thought to be the friendly new front of the firm, started misinterpreting client queries, providing misleading legal responses, or steering potential clients into conversations that were inappropriate or even damaging to the firm’s credibility.
When Automation Becomes an Embarrassment
Let’s not forget, the chatbot is effectively the digital receptionist of your business. It is often the first and only impression a potential client will have when visiting your website. Imagine a potential client arriving on your homepage seeking help with a delicate legal matter and being met with an AI system that offers inaccurate guidance, uses an overly casual tone, or worse, directs them to the wrong service entirely.
There have been real examples of AI bots going rogue. In one instance, a law firm’s chatbot began generating random responses to serious legal questions, telling a user to “consult a psychic” for insight into their divorce. In another, a chatbot continued a conversation about property disputes by offering advice on tax avoidance, a topic entirely unrelated to the user’s concern.
And in one particularly concerning case, an AI chatbot engaging in exchanges with a client more fitting for speed dating. What started as a general enquiry about a corporate law issue soon turned into casual personal chat, completely unrelated to legal services. By the time the business owner reviewed the transcript, the tone had become inappropriate and embarrassing, leaving them shocked at how far off-topic the interaction had gone. It highlighted how uncontrolled automation can cross lines no professional firm would ever allow if a real member of staff were involved.
These may sound absurd, yet they illustrate a growing problem. Once a chatbot is trained on open data and left unsupervised, it can easily go off-script. For a profession built on trust, discretion, and precision, these missteps can cause lasting reputational harm. A single wrong answer or inappropriate response can make your firm appear careless, unprofessional, or even unethical.
The Hidden Risk: Data, Privacy, and Perception
Beyond the public embarrassment, there are deeper risks at play. Many third-party chatbot systems store conversation data externally, meaning confidential or sensitive client information could potentially be logged, analysed, or reused in ways you cannot control. For legal practices handling private matters, this is a dangerous breach of both professional ethics and client confidentiality.
Furthermore, the perception problem is just as damaging. A client expects professionalism from the moment they interact with your firm. When their first conversation is with an AI that feels generic, impersonal, or poorly aligned with your tone of voice, it breaks the connection before it begins. Law firms that have spent years building a strong reputation risk losing trust in seconds because of one ill-judged automation decision.
The Backlash: Firms Returning to Human-Centred Web Dev Solutions
In recent months, LegalClicks has been contacted by a growing number of law firms looking to have these AI chatbot features removed from their websites altogether. What they thought would streamline enquiry handling instead led to confusion, reputation concerns, and client frustration – and that is the true dangers of Rogue AI bots/agents in your law business.
Many are now returning to more reliable and structured solutions, the type of professional web development that allows clients to book meetings, make secure payments, upload documents, sign engagement letters, track case progress, or request consultations directly, without the risk of being misdirected or misinformed. By focusing on clean design, secure integrations, and clear calls to action, these firms are regaining full control of their client experience.
We recently worked with a firm that had installed a third-party AI bot designed to pre-qualify leads. Instead, it repeatedly mishandled cases, marking genuine client enquiries as spam and failing to forward them to the team. The firm lost several high-value cases as a result. Once we replaced the AI system with a custom-built contact structure, their conversion rate improved within weeks.
It is proof that not every new piece of technology fits every business model, especially in sectors where accuracy, privacy, and human connection are essential.
The Smarter Alternative for Legal Practices
The solution is not to reject innovation altogether, but to approach it intelligently. At LegalClicks, we believe that technology should serve the firm’s strategy, not dictate it. When implemented correctly, automation can still help. Appointment scheduling tools, secure client forms, and data-driven CRM systems can all save time without damaging your firm’s image.
The difference lies in control and compliance. Every feature we develop for our legal clients is designed with the firm’s tone, brand, and confidentiality requirements in mind. No automated tool should ever speak on behalf of your business unless it has been thoroughly trained, tested, and reviewed under your supervision.
Your website should reflect your firm’s professionalism, not risk undermining it. That means replacing gimmick chat features with structured systems that guide clients clearly through contact forms, appointment booking, or payment processes, all under your control and aligned with your message.
Finding Your Way Back from a Misjudged AI Move
If your firm has already adopted an AI chatbot and you now find yourself regretting it, you are far from alone. Many firms are discovering that these tools are not the perfect front-of-house solution they were promised. From strange conversations to public embarrassment, the consequences can be serious.
At LegalClicks, we specialise in helping law firms rebuild from these missteps. Whether it is removing malfunctioning chat systems, redesigning your enquiry process, or restoring your website’s professional image, we provide the clarity and reliability your practice needs to regain client confidence.
If you are in a similar situation and want to move away from an AI setup that is no longer serving you, we can help you find a smarter route forward, one that reinstates your business as the trusted local legal firm of choice, not a test site for unreliable automation.
Protect Your Reputation, Not Excuses
Do not settle for excuses. We often hear lines like “it will come good,” “it needs to learn,” “it just needs more data,” or “it’s only a small glitch.” Yet while these reassurances sound harmless, it is your law firm on the line. Every interaction represents your professional standards and your reputation in front of current and potential clients. Your firm, both in person and online, should always reflect the care, ethics, and precision that define your work. Do not become the ‘test case’ for a company promising that their AI solution will “fix everything” or “revolutionise client handling.” It is your name, your credibility, and your livelihood at stake. Are you really willing to risk that, now that we are seeing how some of these examples are playing out in real time?
Shape the Next Chapter of Your Firm with LegalClicks
The legal world is evolving fast, and your online presence should evolve with it. At LegalClicks, we help law firms strengthen their brand, attract better-quality clients, and communicate expertise with confidence. Our team focuses solely on the legal sector, combining intelligent strategy with results-driven marketing to position your firm where it deserves to be. If you are ready to take control of your firm’s digital future, contact us today through our enquiry form or call us on 0800 211 8813 to discover how we can help your practice grow.
We have the perfect services to help promote your Law Firm and build your brand professionally
- Create new or refresh existing law firm branding by using our branding for law firms service.
- Get you a professional looking website online by using our website design for law firms service.
- Use our professional legal marketing services & law firm PPC management services to make sure you get clients.
- Our law firm SEO packages will make sure your website is visible in the Google rankings within your local market.